| 1. | Joseph Licata | 12 | 4:32.70 | North Babylon |
| 2. | Adam Zarrilli | 10 | 4:44.57 | McKee/Staten Island Tech |
| 3. | Matthew Venditti | 10 | 4:45.88 | Monsignor Farrell |
| 4. | John Frederick | 12 | 4:46.87 | North Hunterdon |
| 5. | Daniel Hancock | 11 | 4:47.18 | Saratoga Springs |
| 6. | Brady Ballou | 12 | 4:47.37 | Point Pleasant Boro |
| 7. | Christian Garofano | 12 | 4:47.41 | St Joseph's by the Sea |
| 8. | Nikos Davlouros | 10 | 4:47.66 | Westfield |
| 9. | Marcus Haynia | 12 | 4:47.71 | Westhampton Beach |
| 10. | Griffin Conway | 9 | 4:48.37 | Regis |
| 11. | Ian Catanzano | 11 | 4:48.48 | Gonzaga College |
| 12. | Jonathan Davi | 10 | 4:48.62 | Oceanside |
| 13. | Julian Gargano | 10 | 4:48.73 | Saratoga Springs |
| 14. | Emilo Abdelsayed | 11 | 4:49.01 | Valley Central |
| 15. | Richard Riopel | 11 | 4:49.37 | Marlboro |
| 16. | Eric Beswick | 11 | 4:49.70 | North Hunterdon |
| 17. | Regan Macpherson | 12 | 4:50.17 | St Anthony's |
| 18. | Sean Famighetti | 12 | 4:50.60 | Commack |
| 19. | Max Pirson | 11 | 4:50.77 | New Rochelle |
| 20. | Joshua Melchior | 10 | 4:51.61 | Guilderland |
| 21. | Grahm Burns | 10 | 4:52.18 | Saratoga Springs |
| 22. | Cameron Nicolas | 12 | 4:53.17 | Xavier (NY) |
| 23. | Luke Dembinski | 12 | 4:53.30 | Xaverian |
| 24. | Jason Brown | 12 | 4:53.46 | St Joseph's by the Sea |
| 25. | Seamus Fitzpatrick | 10 | 4:53.54 | Dobbs Ferry |
| 26. | Ben Mayer | 10 | 4:54.31 | Guilderland |
| 27. | Rewa Okubo | 11 | 4:54.36 | Brooklyn Technical |
| 28. | Dylan Koch | 12 | 4:54.84 | Division Avenue (Levittown) |
| 29. | Sean Levy | 12 | 4:54.86 | Guilderland |
| 30. | Rohan Shah | 12 | 4:54.94 | Marlboro |
| 31. | Calvin Daou | 11 | 4:55.29 | Leonia |
| 32. | Matthew Hillmann | 9 | 4:55.36 | North Hunterdon |
| 33. | Thomas Brown | 10 | 4:55.42 | McKee/Staten Island Tech |
| 34. | Oliver Dobek | 11 | 4:55.52 | Westfield |
| 35. | Trevor Szilier | 9 | 4:55.83 | Washington Township |
| 36. | Angelo Valentine | 10 | 4:55.84 | Washington Township |
| 37. | Nick Foster | 12 | 4:56.06 | Monsignor Farrell |
| 38. | Adam Cartano | 12 | 4:57.00 | Regis |
| 39. | Matthew Logozzo | 10 | 4:57.09 | Westfield |
| 40. | Matthew Heffernan | 10 | 4:57.78 | Commack |
| 41. | Abe Hoffmann | 10 | 4:58.02 | Columbia |
| 42. | Lincoln Staiger | 9 | 4:58.33 | Westfield |
| 43. | Brent Kengeri | 10 | 4:58.39 | Westfield |
| 44. | Trace Frederick | 10 | 4:58.46 | North Hunterdon |
| 45. | Jackson Shaw | 10 | 4:58.84 | Saratoga Springs |
| 46. | Timothy Sugrue | 11 | 4:58.99 | Xavier (NY) |
| 47. | Aaron LI | 10 | 4:59.20 | McKee/Staten Island Tech |
| 48. | Akash Pakeerathan | 12 | 4:59.28 | McKee/Staten Island Tech |
| 49. | Will Ard | 12 | 4:59.39 | Summit |
| 50. | Owen Akers | 11 | 5:00.16 | North Hunterdon |
| 51. | Logan Rodriguez | 10 | 5:00.26 | General Douglas Macarthur |
| 52. | Gavin Griffiths | 10 | 5:00.35 | Saratoga Springs |
| 53. | Henry Martin | 12 | 5:01.19 | Columbia |
| 54. | Alessandro Brindisi | 11 | 5:01.25 | Brooklyn Technical |
| 55. | Jake Russo | 11 | 5:01.34 | Longwood |
| 56. | Ryder Kilpatrick | 10 | 5:01.41 | Wallkill |
| 57. | Luke Fragetta | 12 | 5:01.49 | Wallkill |
| 58. | Christian Carbonaro | 9 | 5:02.20 | Oceanside |
| 59. | Zachary Turetsky | 10 | 5:02.31 | Westfield |
| 60. | Jack Ruocchio | 11 | 5:02.57 | General Douglas Macarthur |
| 61. | Ashton Ewald | 10 | 5:02.63 | Valley Central |
| 62. | Liam Lanigan | 10 | 5:02.75 | St Anthony's |
| 63. | Kevin Fernandez | 11 | 5:02.85 | Oceanside |
| 64. | Aidan Rodriguez | 11 | 5:03.08 | New Rochelle |
| 65. | Wyatt Bedor | 11 | 5:03.42 | Marlboro |
| 66. | Richard Maluga | 12 | 5:03.42 | Xavier (NY) |
| 67. | Caleb Fenton | 11 | 5:03.81 | Appoquinimink |
| 68. | Vincent Maffetone | 11 | 5:03.83 | West Islip |
| 69. | Nicholas Fermanian | 11 | 5:03.89 | Pine Bush |
| 70. | Noah Yairi | 11 | 5:03.93 | New Rochelle |
| 71. | Alex Danenhauer | 11 | 5:04.08 | Westfield |
| 72. | Max Vogel | 11 | 5:04.70 | Saratoga Springs |
| 73. | Brycen Smith | 12 | 5:04.74 | Hauppauge |
| 74. | Garrett Borntreger | 12 | 5:04.81 | Appoquinimink |
| 75. | Elias Wysong | 11 | 5:05.14 | North Hunterdon |
| 76. | Jaxson Van Pelt | 10 | 5:05.21 | General Douglas Macarthur |
| 77. | Dylan Blackmon-Friedman | 9 | 5:05.25 | Columbia |
| 78. | Mason Salis | 11 | 5:05.52 | Benjamin Cardozo |
| 79. | Elias Baloyo | 10 | 5:05.59 | General Douglas Macarthur |
| 80. | Alvin Chen | 10 | 5:05.78 | Susan Wagner |
| 81. | Tim Zhuo | 11 | 5:05.82 | McKee/Staten Island Tech |
| 82. | Jordan Cambria | 9 | 5:06.46 | Commack |
| 83. | Declan McGorty | 11 | 5:07.18 | Westfield |
| 84. | Brandon Ruiz | 11 | 5:07.89 | Rancocas Valley Reg |
| 85. | William Emmons | 12 | 5:08.76 | Columbia |
| 86. | Ronnie Guzman | 8 | 5:09.16 | New Rochelle |
| 87. | Matthew Steenweg | 9 | 5:09.17 | Marlboro |
| 88. | Brendan Kilby | 11 | 5:09.23 | Oceanside |
| 89. | Ajdin Bazjzvich | 11 | 5:09.26 | McKee/Staten Island Tech |
| 90. | Jack Llach | 12 | 5:09.48 | St Rose |
| 91. | Alexander Stepanov | 10 | 5:09.67 | Westfield |
| 92. | John Curley | 12 | 5:10.63 | Xaverian |
| 93. | Aidan McClure | 11 | 5:10.83 | Regis |
| 94. | Shreyan Kapale | 8 | 5:11.10 | Shaker |
| 95. | Liam Halpin | 12 | 5:11.33 | Patchogue/Medford |
| 96. | Umar Awais | 11 | 5:12.07 | Marlboro |
| 97. | Kieran Hegde | 12 | 5:12.18 | Xavier (NY) |
| 98. | Peter Galletta | 12 | 5:14.68 | Monsignor Farrell |
| 99. | Lucas Cippitelli | 9 | 5:14.97 | Westfield |
| 100. | Russell Devito | 12 | 5:15.84 | St John The Baptist |
| 101. | Matt Lingenfelter | 12 | 5:16.91 | Loyola Blakefield |
| 102. | James Fabiszewski | 9 | 5:17.02 | Xaverian |
| 103. | Henry Donck | 12 | 5:18.05 | Summit |
| 104. | Scott Kelly | 9 | 5:18.54 | McKee/Staten Island Tech |
| 105. | Yixi Xu | 12 | 5:22.41 | Brooklyn Technical |
| 106. | Sam Abraham | 12 | 5:23.74 | Manhasset |
| 107. | Dylan Herzog | 11 | 5:29.73 | Oceanside |
| 108. | Jose Nieto | 10 | 5:31.33 | Susan Wagner |
Matthew Hillmann Track & Field Result 
